A Fascinating Chronicle of Film Critics: “Opposable Thumbs: How Siskel & Ebert Changed Movies Forever”

Rating: ★★★★☆

In a world where the verdict on a movie relied on the iconic “two thumbs up” from Gene Siskel and Roger Ebert, Matthew Singer’s nonfiction book, “Opposable Thumbs: How Siskel & Ebert Changed Movies Forever,” takes readers on an engaging journey through the evolution of film criticism. While it is a must-read for fans of Siskel and Ebert and those interested in film history, the book could have delved deeper into their personal lives and expanded its scope beyond the end of the “At the Movies” era.

Singer’s storytelling prowess shines as he vividly captures the chance encounter between Siskel and Ebert at a Chicago pub in 1975, showcasing the initial animosity that later transformed into an unlikely friendship. The author skillfully brings to life the conflicts and tension that colored their iconic television show, allowing readers to eavesdrop on their conversations and witness the birth of the legendary “Two thumbs up!” catchphrase.

“Opposable Thumbs” also delves into the duo’s meteoric rise from their humble beginnings on local Chicago PBS to securing multimillion-dollar syndicated contracts. Singer effectively emphasizes Siskel and Ebert’s profound influence on the industry, even inspiring the likes of Oprah Winfrey to follow their path. The book showcases their lasting impact on film criticism and how we perceive movies.

The author’s compassionate exploration of Gene Siskel’s untimely passing, and the secret battle he fought against brain cancer, adds a poignant layer to the narrative. It highlights the depth of their partnership and the missed opportunities for Roger Ebert to say goodbye. These chapters tug at the heartstrings and serve as a reminder of their enduring legacy.

However, “Opposable Thumbs” falls slightly short in certain areas. While the book provides insights into the professional lives of Siskel and Ebert, it could have delved deeper into their personal lives. A more comprehensive understanding of their backgrounds, motivations, and influences would have added an additional layer of richness to the narrative.

Furthermore, as the book progresses after Siskel’s passing, it feels like a hurried journey toward the end of the “At the Movies” era. While the impact of their absence is acknowledged, the narrative could have been more balanced and provided a broader perspective on the continuation of their legacy. More interviews with individuals who Siskel and Ebert inspired to pursue film criticism would have offered valuable insights into their influence on future generations.

“Opposable Thumbs: How Siskel & Ebert Changed Movies Forever” is a captivating and informative tribute to two legendary film critics. Matthew Singer’s storytelling prowess and meticulous research make this book an essential read for fans of Siskel and Ebert, as well as those interested in the history of cinema. However, the book could have delved deeper into their personal lives and provided a more comprehensive exploration beyond the end of the “At the Movies” era. Nevertheless, it remains a fascinating chronicle of their transformative partnership and enduring impact on film criticism.

This film fan and a fan of—still–the two most famous critics of all time give this book two enthusiastic thumbs way up. I also think the book is a wonderful companion to Roger Ebert’s beautiful memoir “Life Itself” and the accompanying documentary.

Thank you to Netgalley and G.P. Putnam’s Sons for the advanced readers’ copy!